Are You Making the Right Security Choice?
Every business faces security risks, including theft, vandalism, and unauthorised access. With various security options available, how do you determine whether security guards or CCTV monitoring is the right choice for your business?
Security is an essential investment, and choosing the wrong approach could result in financial losses, legal issues, and operational setbacks. While CCTV technology has advanced significantly, can it fully replace human security guards? Or is a visible security presence still the most effective deterrent?
This article will explore the costs, effectiveness, scalability, and security impact of CCTV monitoring vs. security guards Perth to help you make the best decision for your business.
CCTV vs. Security Guards Perth: What is Best for Your Business?
Before evaluating which option is more effective, it is important to understand how each works.
Security Guards Perth: The Human Presence
Security guards are trained professionals who monitor premises, enforce security measures, and respond to incidents in real-time.
Their primary benefits include:
- Immediate response to threats
- A strong visual deterrent for criminals
- The ability to intervene physically when necessary
However, security guards in Perth also come with challenges, such as high ongoing costs, potential human error, and limited surveillance coverage.
CCTV Monitoring: The Technological Approach
CCTV monitoring consists of strategically placed surveillance cameras that provide 24/7 remote monitoring of a business. These systems offer:
- Continuous monitoring without breaks or fatigue
- Recorded evidence for legal and insurance purposes
- Lower security costs compared to hiring full-time personnel
Despite these advantages, CCTV lacks real-time human intervention, meaning that while incidents are recorded, there may be delays in response.
How Remote CCTV Monitoring Works
Modern CCTV monitoring uses advanced technology to detect and assess security threats. Standard systems include:
- CCTV cameras to capture activity.
- Motion sensors to detect unauthorised movement.
- Infrared (IR) illuminators for night-time monitoring.
- Alarm Receiving Centres (ARCs) that alert security teams in real-time.
These features make CCTV monitoring a cost-effective, scalable security solution that can protect businesses of all sizes.
Employing Security Guards – An Overview
Hiring security guards in Perth ensures a physical presence that can:
- Prevent security breaches before they occur
- Assist employees and customers
- Respond to emergencies without delay
However, employing security personnel involves:
- High ongoing costs (salaries, benefits, training)
- Shift scheduling challenges to maintain 24/7 security
- Potential liability risks in the case of misconduct
Comparing Remote CCTV Monitoring vs. Security Guards
Both CCTV monitoring and security guards Perth offer unique advantages—CCTV provides continuous surveillance and cost efficiency, while security guards deliver immediate, on-site response and a human presence for added security.
1. Threat Detection and Response
- CCTV Monitoring: Detects suspicious activity instantly and sends alerts to security teams. However, response may be delayed if no personnel are immediately available.
- Security Guards: Can react immediately to threats but may not always be present at the exact location where an incident occurs.
Outcome: Draw: CCTV offers comprehensive surveillance, while guards provide immediate action when on-site.
2. Cost Comparison
When comparing costs, CCTV systems offer a one-time installation fee with minimal ongoing expenses, while security guards require continuous wages, training, and benefits, making CCTV a more budget-friendly long-term solution.
Security Guards:
- Entry-level security guard: $18,000–$22,000 per year.
- Experienced security guard: $22,000–$28,000 per year.
- Security supervisor: Up to $35,000 per year.
CCTV Systems:
- One-time installation cost
- Monthly monitoring fee ($50–$300 per month)
- Up to 90 per cent lower cost than hiring full-time security staff
Outcome: CCTV monitoring is the most affordable option for long-term security.
3. Coverage and Scalability
- CCTV Monitoring: Covers multiple locations at once with minimal staffing.
- Security Guards: Limited to physical presence; larger areas require multiple personnel.
Outcome: CCTV Monitoring offers broader and more scalable coverage.
4. Flexibility and Adaptability
- CCTV Monitoring: Can be upgraded with AI to improve threat detection.
- Security Guards: Require additional training to adapt to evolving security threats.
Outcome: CCTV Monitoring is more adaptable with continuous technological advancements.
Choosing the Right Option for Your Business
The most effective security solution depends on several key factors:
| Factor | CCTV Monitoring | Security Guards |
| Cost | More affordable | Expensive |
| Response Time | Delayed | Immediate |
| Coverage | Large areas | Limited |
| Scalability | Easily expandable | Requires hiring more guards |
| Human Judgment | Lacks decision-making | Provides situational awareness |
For large, low-risk premises, CCTV monitoring is the best choice. For high-risk environments, combining CCTV with security personnel offers maximum protection.
CCTV Monitoring vs. Security Guards: A Quick Summary
- CCTV monitoring is cheaper, scalable, and provides 24/7 surveillance.
- Security guards provide immediate on-site response but come at a higher cost.
- A hybrid approach may be the most effective solution for businesses requiring both continuous surveillance and real-time human intervention.
Final Thoughts: Securing Your Business the Smart Way
To sum up, security guards Perth offer a human touch, but CCTV is cost-effective and scalable. The best solution depends on your business type, security risks, and budget.
For expert security services, consider a hybrid security approach with a mix of CCTV surveillance and trained security guards.
Need help securing your business? Contact Accord Security today for a custom security plan!
📞 Call us now at 08-9456-2622 to discuss your security needs!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What are the advantages of CCTV surveillance for businesses?
CCTV systems provide constant monitoring, deterrence against crime, and valuable evidence in case of legal disputes.
2. How do security guards enhance business security?
They provide on-the-spot response, assist with customer service, and act as a visible deterrent to intruders.
3. Is CCTV enough to protect my business, or do I need security guards as well?
CCTV is effective for general surveillance, but high-risk locations may require security guards for active intervention.
4. What are the costs associated with hiring security guards compared to CCTV systems?
CCTV involves one-time installation costs and minimal monthly fees, while security guards require ongoing salaries and training costs.
5. How do mobile security patrols compare to static security guards?
Mobile patrols cover a wider area, while static guards focus on high-risk locations. Businesses often use a combination of both.